|
Polio:
|
Take Action!
Polio continues to cripple and kill children in over a
dozen countries around the world. Learn
what you can do to pave the way for a polio-free world.
|
What is polio?
How is polio transmitted?
Who is affected by polio?
Where does polio still exist?
How does polio paralyze?
What are the long term effects of paralysis?
What conditions cause the spread of polio?
Who are some famous polio survivors?
Eradication:
What is eradication?
Why is polio targeted for eradication?
How can polio be eradicated?
How is global eradication certified?
How does this compare to smallpox eradication?
Who are the partners in polio eradication?
How do we know if the eradication campaign is working?
What is the legacy of polio eradication?
How will eradicating polio help fight other diseases?
Have other diseases been eradicated?
What is the "cold chain"?
What are NIDs?
What is epidemiology?
What is "herd immunity"?
What is the purpose of the global lab network?
How is poliovirus contained in the laboratory?
What is the "end game strategy"?
Will vaccinations stop after eradication?
Is bioterrorism a concern?
What are the effects on health infrastructure?
What are the challenges of the immunization program?
Why are private organizations like Rotary important
to the eradication campaign?
How does the vaccine work?
How does polio threaten nations already declared
polio-free?
Are vaccinators ever in danger?
What happens if we stop vaccinating now?
What
is polio?
Poliomyelitis is an acute infectious disease caused
by the poliovirus.
"Polio is a viral disease. Its a RNA virus
that is transmitted from person to person through fecal-oral transmission."
Dr. David Sniadack
World Health Organization
"Polio is unique. It can happen only in human
beings -- not like malaria, not like diseases that happen in animals.
This is truly a human disease. Human beings carry it. That's why
we have eradicated smallpox, a similar disease, and we know that
we can eradicate polio."
Dr. T. O. Kyaw-Myint
UNICEF
How is polio transmitted?
"Polio is really very much a disease of children.
First of all, this is the disease which spreads by what we call
the fecal-oral route, so contaminated food or water can spread this
disease, and children, of course, are the ones who often are most
likely to have the least sanitary of habits and thus most efficiently
transmit the virus between themselves. As a result, if you stop
transmission of this virus between young children, you will stop
transmission in a population."
Bruce Aylward
Coordinator, Global Polio Eradication Initiative
World Health Organization
"It's a viral disease that is transmitted from person to person
through fecal-oral transmission. If a child somehow ingests the
virus, that virus will then reproduce in his intestines and that
will then be shed in his stool and spread to anyone in close contact."
Dr. David Sniadack
World Health Organization
"The virus lives in the guts of a child. If there
are 5 million children and five children are missed, maybe the virus
is present in the guts of one of those five missed children. So
it will again circulate, multiply and circulate. And the vaccine
is easy: just drops. If it was an injection it would be harder."
Dr. Mohammad Iqbal Khalil
Pakistan
Who is affected by polio?
"Something like 95 percent of all the people
who get polio are under the age of 5. Theyre all little people.
Some are 4, some are 3, but some are 2 and some are 1, but theyre
little people and I say theyre the most defenseless part of
society."
Bill Sergeant
Chairman of the International PolioPlus Committee
Rotary International
"Over the last two years now, weve seen
the poliovirus become more and more localized geographically, but
also more localized in high risk groups. Now, for example, we know
that urban poor people who are uneducated form the highest risk
group for developing polio, of any of the people of Pakistan. The
Afghan refugees also form a special high-risk group. Children who
live in crowded, poor conditions with poor sanitation and lack of
good water supplies are more likely to be exposed more frequently
to the poliovirus if its in the community. If you think about
the children we still have to vaccinate -- these are the marginal
children of society. These are the poorest, coming from the least
educated families, from the ethnic groups with the least resources
and the least access -- these are the most difficult children to
reach in the whole country. That's why theyre still out there
getting polio."
Dr. Anthony Mounts
World Health Organization
"More cases are in highly congested areas, with
poor sanitary habits and a lot of movement in and out of town. If
you match it with the population density map, the cases are coming
in from areas which are very, very densely populated."
Dr. Hameed Afridi
Deputy Director, EPI (Expanded Program of Immunizations)
NWFP (Northwest Frontier Province)
Provincial Project Manager, Pakistan
How does polio paralyze?
"If a child somehow ingests the virus, that virus
will then reproduce in the child's intestines and then is absorbed
in the intestines and travels to the nerve cells in the spinal cord,
sometimes even in the brain. It has an affinity to receptors in
the spinal cord, and there it does its damage. It decimates nerve
cells of the spinal cord and you become paralyzed."
Dr. David Sniadack
World Health Organization
What are the long-term effects
of paralysis?
"Its a terrible crime to have paralyzed
children who are going to be, in a sense, crippled and deformed
for life. It's going to have a big impact on their life and what
they can do in their life. They don't have access to crutches, to
a wheelchair, or to braces. And in many cases they're also denied
an education. The child cant walk to school and the parents
are working, so they can't carry her. In a country like Angola,
polio excludes you from so many things. Chances of marriage are
very, very slim because people aren't going to want to marry somebody
who cant work. Your chances of supporting yourself in a country
where its mostly agrarian farmers who rely on physical labor
are extremely limited if you are paralyzed. If you are a child,
you cant play with the other children. So many things."
Lee Losey
Director
CORE Angola Secretariat
"Any time you have a child who is unable to grow
healthily and a child who is unable to contribute to a family structure,
you have an enormous burden and toll on the family."
Jeff Ashley
U.S. Agency for International Development
"They end up doing very menial jobs if any at
all: selling newspapers, begging. There are not many resources to
help them. If they live in the rural areas, its a terrible
situation. Ive seen these people just dragging themselves
though the dirt and begging, and they just look like theyre
living in horrible circumstances. Of course, the women would never
even be allowed out of the house if they were paralyzed. Theyd
have no hope of ever being married or having a normal life. They
would be totally dependent. Its a very tragic situation. When
you drive around Pakistan, you see newspaper vendors on the street
-- they walk along with crutches and little withered legs. Or you
see men who are peddling tricycles that they peddle by hand. These
are all polio victims."
Dr. Anthony Mounts
World Health Organization
What conditions cause the spread
of polio?
"The virus is directly related to your exposure
of fecal material. So in the developed world, of course, the exposure
is much less than in the developing world. If you have no access
to clean water youre at higher risk than if you have access
to chlorinated water. But even in the developed world the process
of changing diapers can expose you to the virus. So, even things
that we consider relatively routine do present a mechanism for transmitting
the virus. Most of the adults, however, are immune, so theyre
not at risk of disease. But if you have other children playing together
and contaminating toys that are shared, then the virus can be spread
that way. Therefore, in daycare settings or equivalent, the viruses
can indeed spread. The risk is directly related to the social situation
and the infrastructure of a community."
Dr. Mark Pallansch
Chief of the Enterovirus Section in the National Center for
Infectious Diseases
Centers for Disease Control and Prevention
"Its the 21st century and still we are
lacking a sewage system. The majority of our areas have no safe
system at all. They depend on septic tanks. That creates a problem,
because our underground water is spoiled, its polluted. You
cant trust our underground water, which is supposed to be
safe drinking water. This is an enormous problem. We have to take
care of this problem if we want to get rid of infectious disease."
Dr. Mohammad Iqbal Khalil
Pakistan
Who are some famous polio survivors?
- Eleanor Abbott -- Designed the game CandyLand
- Tenley Albright -- Doctor and Olympic gold medalist for
figure skating
- Alan Alda -- Actor, writer, director
- Ann Adams (1937-1992) -- Artist paralyzed by polio (painted
with her mouth)
- Claudius (10 B.C. to 54 A.D.) -- Emperor of Rome
- Tanaquil Le Clercq (1929-2000) -- Ballet dancer
- Judy Collins -- Singer
- Francis Ford Coppola -- Film director
- Sir Julian Critchley (1930-2000) -- Journalist, author
and member of the House of Commons
- Bill Cullen (1920-1990) -- Game show host
- Buddy Daley -- Baseball All-star (1959 and 1960)
- William Orville Douglas (1898-1980) -- Associate Justice,
U.S. Supreme Court
- Mia Farrow -- Actress
- Mel Ferrar -- Actor
|
- William Alexander Gadsby -- NHL, Hall of Fame (1970)
- John Hager -- Lieutenant Governor, Virginia
- Frida Kahlo (1907-1954) -- Mexican painter
- Frank Mars (1883-1933) -- Founded M&M Mars chocolate company
- Martin Milner -- Actor
- Joni Mitchell -- Singer
- Jack Nicklaus -- Golfer
- Itzhak Perlman -- Internationally acclaimed violinist
- Owen Roizman -- Cinematographer, Five Oscar nominations
and Lifetime Achievement Award
- Franklin Delano Roosevelt (1882-1945) -- US president
- David Sanborn -- Saxophonist
- Sir John Cotesworth Slessor (1897-1979) -- British Marshall
in the Royal Air Force in World War II
- Donald Sutherland -- Actor
- Nyla Thompson -- Artist (using mouth)
- Neil Young -- 1970s and 1980s Canadian rock singer
|
What is eradication?
"We use eradication of a disease to speak of
completely getting rid of it. That is, that the disease does not
exist anywhere within a country, and then finally any place within
the world."
Lee Losey
Director
CORE Angola Secretariat
Why is polio targeted for eradication?
"There are some characteristics for a disease
to be eradicable, like it infects only human beings so that there
is no animal reservoir for that infectious agent. It's transmitted
only from person to person without the intervention of a mosquito
or the environment. And if you survive after the infection you have
immunity forever, so you don't get sick again. And you have a good
intervention like a vaccine."
Dr. Ciro de Quadros
Director, Division of Vaccines and Immunizations
Pan American Health Organization
"By eradicating polio, we prevent over 350,000
cases of paralysis a year and that offers these children a full
life -- if they can walk, if they can be part of their community,
if they can earn a livelihood, if they can marry and have children
of their own."
Ellyn W. Ogden
Worldwide Polio Eradication Coordinator/Senior Technical Advisor
for Health and Child Survival
U.S. Agency for International Development
How can polio be eradicated?
"To eradicate a disease like polio, you have
to stop the transmission of the wild poliovirus. You do that by
immunizing all the children in the world against the disease. You
hold National Immunization Days, where children and mothers and
fathers come to a center and they get immunized. You also do house-to-house
strategy. You go out into the villages or into the communities and
you knock on all the doors, and you ask them to bring out the children
and immunize those children. And you mark the house with chalk to
say this house has been immunized."
Carol Pandak
PolioPlus Division Manager
Rotary International
"Polio eradication is largely a matter of logistics.
You basically have to do two things. You have to vaccinate 90 percent
of all children under 5. And that's largely logistics. Then you
have to do good surveillance. That is, you have to find the cases.
To find the cases you need to be in the communities. Thats
where the non-governmental organizations (NGOs) are. They've got
volunteers out in the communities doing all kinds of public health
work."
Lee Losey
Director
CORE Angola Secretariat
"What were trying to do is to get enough
vaccine out into circulation, circulating among the population so
that the virus has no place to go. The wild virus will die out in
a matter of weeks if its got no place to go -- if it cant
re-infect another child. So by vaccinating all of the children in
the community, you create a barrier to the virus and it goes away.
So we have to tell people, we have to make them understand that
even if their child is protected, or if their child got vaccinated
in the last campaign, they still need to get vaccinated in this
one. Because it's for the good of everyone. And if they dont
get vaccinated, then well never stop this disease from spreading."
Dr. Anthony Mounts
World Health Organization
"If the only cases that ever occur of polio in
the future are vaccine-derived cases, I think the public health
community is entirely justified in trumpeting its success in eradicating
the natural occurrence of this disease."
Dr. Ronald Waldman
Medical Epidemiologist, Professor of Clinical Public Health
Columbia University
How is global eradication certified?
"The first thing you have to do is eliminate
the disease so you don't find it anymore. But then you have to monitor
for another three years to make sure it's not there, so you can
certify that it's gone. Maybe you've missed some cases, maybe there
are some villages that didn't get to it, maybe there are some people
on an airplane that didn't get vaccinated. So, it's about three
years after the elimination of polio that we can then declare that
it has been eradicated."
Tim Wirth
President
U.N. Foundation
How does this effort compare to
smallpox eradication?
"Polio eradication is more challenging than smallpox
for several reasons. One, the number of countries that were endemic
at the beginning of the program was much larger than at the start
of the smallpox eradication program. Polio eradication actually
consists of eradicating three viruses, not just one, as with smallpox.
The other problem is that poliovirus infection does not always cause
disease in the patient it infects. Smallpox always has clinically
evident disease. So just by looking at a patient, one is able to
track the smallpox virus. Whereas with poliovirus, you can have
hundreds of infected individuals before you will ever see a child
paralyzed. The surveillance activities are much different for polio
than they are for smallpox."
Dr. Mark Pallansch
Chief of the Enterovirus Section in the National Center for
Infectious Diseases
Centers for Disease Control and Prevention
"I think its difficult to say which is
more challenging: smallpox eradication or polio eradication. But
the programs and the challenges are fairly different. We have a
much bigger global population than we had in the 1960s and 1970s,
when we were trying to eradicate smallpox. Many new conflicts have
arisen since we launched the eradication initiative against polio.
Youll remember that 10 years ago, much of D.R. Congo was not
at war. Much of Afghanistan was a lot quieter than it was in the
last couple of years; similarly, Somalia. With polio, because it
can spread so fast to anywhere in the world, we have to maintain
a global surveillance program, we have to maintain global immunization,
we have to maintain massive immunization days in countries that
have been polio-free for relatively long periods."
Bruce Aylward
Coordinator, Global Polio Eradication Initiative
World Health Organization
How do we know if the eradication
campaign is working?
"Theres a set of criteria for polio certification.
An outside body is going to come in and look largely at the surveillance
system that a country has. You expect one case of acute flaccid
paralysis in every 100,000 children under the age of 15 in a normal
population if theres no polio. So a test of whether or not
youve got a strong surveillance system is if you are finding
that one case of paralysis in every 100,000 children under 15 in
a nation. Thats an indicator of whether or not your surveillance
system is good. Another indicator of a strong surveillance system
is that you not only find the paralysis cases, but that you find
them within two weeks of onset in order to do the laboratory analysis
of the stool sample to tell whether it's polio or not."
Lee Losey
Director
CORE Angola Secretariat
"Surveillance is the eagle eye through which
you can assess your health system. It helps us plan for the future.
I think this is the most useful thing that has come out of the polio
campaign."
Dr. Hameed Afridi
Deputy Director, EPI (Expanded Program of Immunizations)
NWFP (Northwest Frontier Province)
Provincial Project Manager, Pakistan
"Surveillance tells us how were doing.
You know, how we need to fine tune our efforts. And where we are
along the timeline for polio eradication."
Dr. Olen Kew
Chief of the Molecular Virology Section of the Division of Viral
Diseases
Centers for Disease Control and Prevention
"Surveillance is not something that stops during
the last campaign of our National Immunization Day. Surveillance
mechanisms are extremely important to monitor and track and ensure
that we are not seeing anymore cases."
Jeff Ashley
U.S. Agency for International Development
What is the legacy of polio eradication?
"I think that maybe the single most important
legacy of polio eradication is the end of acceptance of the continued
incidence of vaccine preventable diseases in poor countries."
Dr. Olen Kew
Chief of the Molecular Virology Section of the Division of Viral
Diseases
Centers for Disease Control and Prevention
"When we look at the legacy of polio eradication,
I think we have to try to ensure that we do more than eradicate
this disease. We have to ensure we reach every child, every community,
and eradicate the disease. By doing so, we open a door to bring
more things, to bring anti-malarials, to bring bed nets to protect
children against malaria, to bring clean water, to bring surveillance
for other important diseases. That must be our goal: not only to
eradicate the disease, but to help communities help themselves to
do a lot more for the children."
Bruce Aylward
Coordinator, Global Polio Eradication Initiative
World Health Organization
"An immediate legacy of polio eradication will
be a reinforcement of the commitment to eliminate and eradicate
measles, and I can tell you from my own experience that in the developing
world, the people are waiting for us."
Dr. Olen Kew
Chief of the Molecular Virology Section of the Division of Viral
Diseases
Centers for Disease Control and Prevention
"I think the legacy of polio -- and what it has
contributed in the broader strengthening of health systems -- is
very, very complex, and can be measured in many, many different
ways. One small thing that polio eradication has done has been to
include vitamin A in many of the polio immunization days. Just that
simple thing of adding vitamin A drops has prevented, we estimate,
over a million childhood deaths in the last few years alone. So
in many, many ways, whether in terms of investments in the broader
health systems or actual outcomes, we believe that the polio eradication
initiative has had a real impact. In the closing years of the polio
eradication program, we have to make sure now that the infrastructure
weve established -- the institutional arrangements, the human
infrastructure, the physical infrastructure -- that we build on
all of that and we structure it in a way that it can continue to
contribute to many other areas of immunization, of surveillance
and broader health work."
Bruce Aylward
Coordinator, Global Polio Eradication Initiative
World Health Organization
"USAID has always focused on trying to mitigate
conflict, to try to establish systems and provide services that
will encourage a transition to peace and a stable government and
democracy over time. And we feel that polio eradication contributes
greatly to those goals."
Ellyn W. Ogden
Worldwide Polio Eradication Coordinator/Senior Technical Advisor
for Health and Child Survival
U.S. Agency for International Development
"The benefits are larger than you might think.
The obvious one is the fact that we wont have to vaccinate
for polio anymore. So all the resources that are spent buying polio
vaccine, distributing polio vaccine -- all of this can be diverted
to something else. But the biggest benefit to society is: people
who are crippled from polio, especially in places like Pakistan,
theyre not productive, contributing members of society. It
takes a lot of money to support them. And this can be fixed, this
can be prevented. There's also the savings to medical budgets. It
takes a lot of money to take care of polio victims. All of that
can be reallocated for other needs."
Dr. Anthony Mounts
World Health Organization
How will eradicating polio help
fight other diseases?
"[Once polio is eradicated,] it will be a great
victory for the global public health network. A real sense of confidence
will build a base for the next set of issues, which are malaria,
measles and ultimately, of course, the huge challenge of working
on AIDS around the world."
Tim Wirth
President
UN Foundation
"We are learning that the efforts to eradicate
polio in the poorer parts of the world, particularly in sub-Saharan
Africa, are bringing a tremendous benefit for the health infrastructure.
So I believe that because of polio eradication, the African countries
will be in a much better condition to fight the HIV/AIDS epidemic."
Dr. Ciro de Quadros
Director, Division of Vaccines and Immunizations
Pan American Health Organization
"I think there are a lot of things weve
learned from this experience that can be applied to HIV. We did
the same thing with polio: we built on the experience from smallpox
eradication. We used a lot of those lessons to plan polio eradication,
and I think well do the same with HIV. Weve learned
a lot about surveillance and community involvement, and I think
these lessons can now be used, especially if theres a vaccine
for HIV developed in the near future, to implement some kind of
control projects for HIV."
Dr. Anthony Mounts
World Health Organization
"Hopefully there will be a cadre of people who
have been brought into the public health system and hopefully there
will be a heightened awareness of the importance of public health
programs that there will be some transfer of emotion and expertise
from the polio program to the ongoing efforts to control HIV/AIDS."
Dr. Ronald Waldman
Medical Epidemiologist, Professor of Clinical Public Health
Columbia University
"The experience with polio and the global program
working together is a very positive one that we're going to have
to draw on for dealing with SARS, because it's almost certainly
going to be a problem we're going to be dealing with for a long
time."
Dr. D.A. Henderson
Johns Hopkins University
"The world is tackling a number of things right
now, like improved malaria, HIV/AIDS and tuberculosis control. I
think polio has a lot to teach about how to maintain the political
interest and partner/donor interests on those kind of topics, because
I think polio has done a very, very good job."
Robert Steinglass
Immunization Team Leader
BASICS
Have other diseases been eradicated?
"The only effort so far globally that succeeded
was smallpox, and now hopefully polio will be the next one. The
others failed because the disease, from the outset, was not eradicable."
Dr. Ciro de Quadros
Director, Division of Vaccines and Immunizations
Pan American Health Organization
"There have been in history a number of efforts
at eradication. It began with hookworm. It's moved on to yellow
fever, to yaws, and malaria. Each of these have failed. When we
got to the smallpox eradication program, there were many who said
eradication itself was impossible. We did not believe that. We believed
we could do it with smallpox. We did succeed."
Dr. DA Henderson
Johns Hopkins University
What is the "cold chain"?
"The cold chain, which is a series of refrigeration
and ice packs and other modes of keeping vaccine cold, is very important.
From point of manufacturing until that drop gets into the child,
we make sure that that vaccine is kept as cold as possible until
we can give it and assure that it's in good quality. Manufacturers
have agreed to use a little monitor on the vaccine vial. It's called
a vaccine vial monitor marker. This little vial changes color with
exposure to heat over time, and that lets us know if the vaccine
is potent at the point of use."
Ellyn W. Ogden
Worldwide Polio Eradication Coordinator/Senior Technical Advisor
for Health and Child Survival
U.S. Agency for International Development
"When we were involved in the smallpox eradication
program, we had to create a system for preserving the vaccine. We
call it the cold chain system. "
David Newberry
Senior Health Advisor
CARE
"Polio has brought in a lot of cold chain equipment.
This is equipment to maintain the integrity of the vaccine."
Robert Steinglass
Immunization Team Leader
BASICS
What are National Immunization
Day's (NIDs)?
"The National Immunization Days are days in which
you immunize all the children in the country, under 5, on a single
day. It's a massive effort."
Bill Sergeant
Chairman of the International PolioPlus Committee
Rotary International
What is epidemiology?
"An epidemiologist investigates epidemics or
outbreaks, the underlying causes of disease. In our area, the epidemiologists
are really adhering to the traditional role of epidemiologists for
the last two or three centuries, which is to understand the underlying
routes of infectious disease and the risk factors which permit the
continued transmission of polio virus. What are the risks? What
are the causes? And then what are the interventions? What are the
public health steps that are essential to stopping the transmission
or eliminating the risk of polio?"
Dr. Olen Kew
Chief of the Molecular Virology Section of the Division of Viral
Diseases
Centers for Disease Control and Prevention
"An epidemiologist is often some kind of detective
of disease, you might say. You are kind of a sleuth, a detective
trying to look at the places, look at the clues and find a solution.
If its a disease that has not yet been discovered, then youve
got some signs to look at and you try to figure out whats
causing this. Who gets it? Where do they get it? What caused this?
Once youve already got a disease, you bring in epidemiologists
to use some of those same tools to let us know how were doing,
where the disease is, are we eradicating it."
Lee Losey
Director
CORE Angola Secretariat
What is "herd immunity"?
"What we mean by herd immunity is if you vaccinate
a certain percentage of a population that might be susceptible to
the disease, then it will protect the rest of the population. If
you visualize 100 people standing in a room within arms length
of just the four people that are closest to them, if you immunized
90 percent of the people in that room (thus only 10 people randomly
spread through the room have not been vaccinated), and you bring
in one person with polio, the likelihood is that that person with
polio is not going to come in contact with the 10 people who are
not vaccinated. And if, by chance, the person with polio does come
into contact with one of those 10 people, that person will be surrounded
by other people who are vaccinated, so when the virus tries to pass
itself onto the next person, it will be blocked. Different diseases
require different percentages for herd immunity to be achieved.
Ninety percent is what we think the target should be for polio herd
immunity."
Lee Losey
Director
CORE Angola Secretariat
What is the purpose of the global
lab network?
"The purpose of the laboratory is to distinguish
those cases of paralysis that are due to poliovirus from all other
causes of paralytic disease. The genomic sequencing of the virus
will also tell information about where the virus came from, whether
it's indigenous, a native virus to that country, or it's an importation."
Dr. Mark Pallansch
Chief of the Enterovirus Section in the National Center for Infectious
Diseases
Centers for Disease Control and Prevention
"You need a laboratory not only to identify whether
it's polio or not that's causing the illness, but which type of
polio. And for that a laboratory network has been built from the
earliest days to support the initiative."
Dr. Olen Kew
Chief of the Molecular Virology Section of the Division of Viral
Diseases
Centers for Disease Control and Prevention
"The lab work is part of a surveillance system.
It is the eyes of the program. It is the attempt to look for where
the wild virus is. And this is a system that is dependent on all
of the steps, from identifying paralyzed children through having
specimens collected and tested in a laboratory that is able to identify
the presence of the virus."
Dr. Mark Pallansch
Chief of the Enterovirus Section in the National Center for
Infectious Diseases
Centers for Disease Control and Prevention
"There is always a challenge in building such
a comprehensive global network where none has existed before. This
is really the first time in human history that a worldwide network
operating to uniform and high standards of performance has been
built for any infectious disease, and there are a number of challenges
with that. Most of those challenges have been overcome with the
strong support of WHO and WHOs partners. And of course with
the virologists themselves in each and every country where theres
a laboratory that enthusiastically supports the idea of polio eradication."
Dr. Olen Kew
Chief of the Molecular Virology Section of the Division of Viral
Diseases
Centers for Disease Control and Prevention
How is poliovirus contained in
the laboratory?
"The containment at this stage involves developing
an inventory of those laboratories around the world that have poliovirus
or have materials which could potentially contain poliovirus. So
the inventory is the first phase. The second phase is to assure
that those materials are handled in a safe way that does not pose
a risk of the virus leaving the laboratory."
Dr. Mark Pallansch
Chief of the Enterovirus Section in the National Center for
Infectious Diseases
Centers for Disease Control and Prevention
"A great part of our work right now is to make
sure that we have identified every laboratory in the world that
still has poliovirus or still works with poliovirus or may still
have the virus and not even know about it. So we have to identify
those labs, survey those laboratories, and then with the help of
those laboratories, establish a program to make sure that the viruses
are appropriately managed, safely and securely stored, such that
they will not pose a risk to their communities. This is a big job.
Its a massive logistical effort, but the work done today suggests
that this is very, very feasible."
Bruce Aylward
Coordinator, Global Polio Eradication Initiative
World Health Organization
"If you have hundreds of laboratories that have
poliovirus in their freezers or potentially infectious materials,
then its important as we get close to the last case of naturally
occurring polio to determine through an inventory which laboratories
do have samples, materials that may be a potential threat to the
reintroduction of poliovirus after the last naturally occurring
case."
Dr. Steve Cochi
Division Director, Vaccine Preventable Disease Eradication
Centers for Disease Control and Prevention
"We're not looking at destroying every stock
of poliovirus around the world. What were making sure of is
that the barrier between that virus and the community is as secure
as possible. And there are many, many levels to that barrier just
in case one of those should break down. It is very, very difficult
even now for a poliovirus to just leave a laboratory and re-infect
a community. We have not seen that happen so far, even before we
started this containment program."
Bruce Aylward
Coordinator, Global Polio Eradication Initiative
World Health Organization
What is the "end game strategy"?
"There are three or four scenarios. The first
scenario will be that you will have a sort of global immunization
day and then everybody stops vaccinating at the same day. We know
from experiences in Cuba that after two or three months, the [vaccine]
virus disappears from the environment. The second one would be that
you'd have another vaccine with the live virus attenuated that would
not have the property of reversion to virulence, which is very complicated.
A third scenario would be that you would switch and replace the
oral vaccine with the inactivated vaccine. And what we need now
is to look into these scenarios and see which one really would work."
Dr. Ciro de Quadros
Director, Division of Vaccines and Immunizations
Pan American Health Organization
"Can you imagine getting every country in the
world at this point in time to take a day, a week, a month, and
vaccinate all our children? I dont think so. There are so
many problems in so many parts of the world, and so many agendas
that different countries have, that this is sheer fantasy to believe
that you could do this."
Dr. DA Henderson
Johns Hopkins University
"Its like weve got the virus cornered.
We just have to really move in and attack it hard this time. But
it takes a massive effort. The children who we're trying to reach
now are the ones who are least reachable -- the most marginal of
society. And so weve got to push and push and push and throw
a lot of manpower and a lot of resources into it. But if we can
do this, the payback is going to be huge. Eventually we'll be able
to stop buying polio vaccine and we can refocus on something else.
If we can do this -- if we dont give up here at the last minute
-- if we can really do this, its going to have eternal benefits."
Dr. Anthony Mounts
World Health Organization
Will vaccinations stop after
eradication?
"When we eradicate polio from the world, we'd
like to stop vaccinating, because stopping the vaccination is the
major gain that you have in terms of the savings, and of course
you won't have anybody paralyzed anymore if you eradicate the disease.
So when we eradicate polio, we want to stop vaccinating."
Dr. Ciro de Quadros
Director, Division of Vaccines and Immunizations
Pan American Health Organization
"There is now increasing talk not so much of
eradicating polio but maintaining eradication. In other words, this
will continue to require investments over time, and the likelihood
of stopping polio vaccine, which is the big economic payoff of polio
eradication, starts to recede into the distance unfortunately."
Robert Steinglass
Immunization Team Leader
BASICS
"We're not going to be able to stop vaccination
worldwide at any point in time no matter what we do. You're always
going to have unvaccinated children. Are we then thinking that two
years or five years later we will begin to have cases again as a
result of reversion to virulence? I would say you have to think
that. You have to assume that's going to happen."
Dr. DA Henderson
Johns Hopkins University
"Some events like September 11th, need to be
considered. It's unlikely that many governments would agree to allow
their population over time to become susceptible to serious disease
by stopping vaccination."
Robert Steinglass
Immunization Team Leader
BASICS
Is bioterrorism a concern?
"Some scares related to smallpox have caused
some concern about polio, which should not be a concern because
theyre in completely different categories. Ive often
said that I didnt think any self-respecting terrorist would
ever choose polio, which, of the children it infects, only 1 percent
are ever paralyzed. There are many agents which are much more serious."
Bill Sergeant
Chairman of the International PolioPlus Committee
Rotary International
"Obviously, a virus which only causes one case
of paralytic disease in 200 would seem to not be a very good biological
weapon. But I would remind everyone concerned: suppose we stopped
polio vaccination and suppose someone decided to reintroduce it.
Back in the 1950s when we had polio [in the United States], in the
summers we were closing swimming pools, we were keeping children
at home, we were isolating families. We did many things because
of the fear and terror that polio engendered, and the fact that
it would cause paralytic disease in children of the wealthy and
of the poor, even those who were in their teens and older. There
was immense fear. Yes, polio could be used as a weapon."
Dr. DA Henderson
Johns Hopkins University
What are the effects on health
infrastructure?
"The polio eradication program has brought over
a billion dollars in new money over the last 20 years to routine
immunization programs. Those dollars have bought vehicles for much
of sub-Saharan Africa and Asia for immunization and surveillance
programs. It has bought refrigerators to store other vaccines in,
not only polio vaccines. Its trained hundreds of thousands
of people to give polio vaccines and vitamin A and other simple
health interventions. It's trained tens of thousands of health workers
around the world to be able to investigate, detect and respond to
other important public health problems."
Bruce Aylward
Coordinator, Global Polio Eradication Initiative
World Health Organization
"If theres one huge benefit globally, that
would be the tremendous advances in laboratories. The international
laboratory scene has moved into the 21st century, and that is a
result of the polio eradication effort."
David Newberry,
Senior Health Advisor
CARE
"Because of the door-to-door campaign, the population
now feels it is their right that everything should be provided them
there. So for all other vaccination purposes, they dont turn
up at the health facility. That is one real setback that we had
because of polio. But the positive things that have come out of
the polio initiative have been so many, like the micro plan, the
maps of every area. Everybody knows what theyre supposed to
do, logistics training has happened. Surveillance is the main thing.
Were not just doing polio were doing measles
and tetanus already. And then this effort can be replicated for
other purposes."
Dr. Hameed Afridi
Deputy Director, EPI (Expanded Program of Immunizations)
NWFP (Northwest Frontier Province)
Provincial Project Manager, Pakistan
"Many laboratories have been strengthened beyond
a shadow of a doubt. Reporting systems, particularly for those diseases
of epidemic potential, have certainly been strengthened -- just
by virtue of so many people being out in the villages and so many
extra eyes being able to see and record what's occurring with the
health status of the population."
Dr. Ronald Waldman
Medical Epidemiologist, Professor of Clinical Public Health
Columbia University
What are the challenges of the
immunization program?
"The country borders are so porous that it is
difficult to check who has been immunized and who has not been immunized.
In the northern part of Niger, the weather is hot. And where you
don't have electricity, its difficult to keep the oral polio
vaccine in an acceptable temperature situation. Even if you have
it for a little while, the potency is gone through the heat. Another
challenge that we have is one of illiteracy. And another challenge
is that there are nomadic people moving from one place to another,
so you have got to be with them to be able to know who has been
immunized or not."
Jonathan Majiyagbe
Rotary International
The big challenge is competing. Youre
competing in a world of so many priorities -- a world where so many
good efforts that are ongoing need financing. And there's just so
little financing going into public sector initiatives such as polio
eradication, such as malaria, such as HIV/AIDS."
Bruce Aylward
Coordinator, Global Polio Eradication Initiative
World Health Organization
"The great challenge has been where civil strife
occurs, and those have been among the last countries for us to reach.
Immunizing a child while people are shooting at you is indeed a
very, very challenging problem."
Bill Sergeant
Chairman of the International PolioPlus Committee
Rotary International
Right now, Africa seems to be the melting point
of a lot of conflict. Youve heard about Congo, you heard about
Angola, Sierra Leone, Liberia. All those areas have made it very,
very difficult to have immunization. Agencies like WHO and the UN
were able to broker days of tranquility. But then, what do you do
in areas like Angola where you have landmines? Sometimes, Rotarians
go to these areas, only themselves to be attacked by people living
there."
Jonathan Majiyagbe
Rotary International
"Conflict countries are proving to be one of
the most difficult areas for polio eradication. Its not only
a function of getting access into areas, but also a function of
funding the activities that are needed. Typically, USAID and other
donors do not put money into what we would call hostile countries."
Ellyn W. Ogden
Worldwide Polio Eradication Coordinator/Senior Technical Advisor
for Health and Child Survival
U.S. Agency for International Development
"Sometimes, it almost feels like theres
a force out there that is resisting. Sometimes I think the force
is apathy. Thats really what we have to overcome: the apathy.
People are getting tired. Theyre tired of all the campaigns.
Theyre tired of us coming back to their houses every six weeks.
And thats the force were fighting against: the apathy."
Dr. Anthony Mounts
World Health Organization
"Funding remains the most serious challenge.
Purchasing four-wheel vehicles to get back in very difficult areas
and finding people who can take the vaccine back to the remote areas
and deliver it. This turns out to be more costly than buying the
vaccine itself."
Bill Sergeant
Chairman of the International PolioPlus Committee
Rotary International
"We need women on the vaccination teams. This
is because of the cultural restrictions. Strange men cant
enter a home where theyre not related. If theres no
male relative at home, a woman with a small child will not let a
male vaccinator into the house. She probably will not even meet
him at the door. That means we have to recruit women to be on the
vaccination teams. This causes us some problems, because in some
of the more conservative areas, they dont allow their own
wives and daughters to go out and move through the communities.
We have to recruit women from outside the community. That adds another
logistic hurdle."
Dr. Anthony Mounts
World Health Organization
"Nomads and children living in brick kilns have
always been seen by us as a special challenge. This is because theyre
either moving, or they're so remote from the rest of the population.
When you're making plans, those are not seen as regular places where
people live, so they're not counted in the plans. Sometimes they're
so far away that, even if a team is assigned, it's difficult to
get there."
Raana Syed
Chief, Program Support Communication Section
UNICEF
"Logistically, theres always a problem
with transportation. We try and get volunteers and workers from
within their own community, so that transportation is not such an
issue. But theres still the issue of trying to deliver the
vaccine, the supplies, the ice -- all of the paperwork that needs
to be filled out. Its a very big logistical problem."
Dr. Anthony Mounts
World Health Organization
Why are private organizations
like Rotary important to the eradication campaign?
"I think to include the humanitarian organizations,
non-governmental organizations of a variety of sorts, is an extremely
valuable instrument. I think it's because these are people working
in communities who know the communities and who have a variety of
different contacts as a result of programs that are already operating."
Dr. DA Henderson
Johns Hopkins University
"The pressure that's been put on by a private
organization like the Rotary Foundation is in fact quite a good
thing. I think that there is definitely something to be said for
shaking up a public health establishment that was somewhat complacent
about its ability to achieve remarkable things such as polio eradication.
Increased demand from the lay community creates pressure to provide
services. That kind of activism, that kind of insistence on better
services for more people is in many ways what the donors ought to
be hearing, not just hearing from the self-interested public health
community."
Dr. Ronald Waldman
Medical Epidemiologist, Professor of Clinical Public Health
Columbia University
Is it appropriate to impose a
global health initiative on individual countries?
"If I am an administrator of health and you come
to my country and want to encourage me to do something about, Guinea
Worm, for instance, and Ive got a stack of death reports on
my desk from measles, diphtheria, tetanus, or any other disease,
my obligation and my priority may be different from yours. At a
national level, individual countries have their own priorities,
and it's not fair, I dont think, for us to dictate what those
priorities should be. Nor should we take offense when they choose
priorities that may be different than we on a global scale might
suggest is important."
David Newberry
Senior Health Advisor
CARE
How does the vaccine work?
"It gives you just enough of the disease so that
your natural immune system will recognize it and put up a defense
when the real disease comes knocking, but not enough to make you
sick. So you get just a small bit of the disease. And that's the
case with polio. Now, there are essentially two kinds of vaccines.
Theres live attenuated -- it's the actual virus, its
the actual disease -- but its a very watered down version
of it. So you take just a small bit."
Lee Losey
Director
CORE Angola Secretariat
How does polio threaten nations
already declared polio-free?
"Every child's health is dependent on his neighborhood.
The world is a big neighborhood now. And America is the same way.
If we don't protect, if we don't do something about our neighbors
in Pakistan, America is still at risk. And the same for every country."
Dr. Anthony Mounts
World Health Organization
"The presence of a polio case in any part of
the world will have implications for all the world. In this age
of travel, where you can move from one country to another with such
ease, you can carry a virus with you."
Dr. Rahan Hafiz
National Program Manager
Expanded Program of Immunization (EPI), Pakistan
"Polio is a virus and as such, a virus does not
know borders, does not know international borders, does not know
provincial borders and does not discriminate against people, or
children particularly. Poliovirus can jump any border, can jump
any province and can infiltrate. The whole effort towards eradication
in polio is to vaccinate as many children as possible to develop
and increase that immunity so that the poliovirus cannot attach
itself to that child and create disease. This is what is important
to keep in mind: that any kind of virus or bacterial disease doesn't
see borders and does not see human faces. It does not discriminate."
Jeff Ashley
U.S. Agency for International Development
Are vaccinators ever in danger?
"One of the biggest fears of the program is that
vaccinators lose their life or people working in the program lose
their life. We don't enter eradication easily. People think that
just by immunizing kids, it's all wonderful. But every day there
are acts of bravery; every day people put their lives on the line
for polio eradication. Many vaccinators have been killed trying
to get vaccine out to kids in the farthest reaches of not only conflict
countries, but anywhere that has remote access and can't get to
children easily. Boats tip over, vehicles slide off the side of
the road and sometimes people get shot. That is our worst nightmare."
Ellyn W. Ogden
Worldwide Polio Eradication Coordinator/Senior Technical Advisor
for Health and Child Survival
U.S. Agency for International Development
"I'm amazed that people go out and do this, knowing
that the area is at high-risk, knowing that they could be killed
or wounded or robbed. And we do try to take precautions."
David Newberry
Senior Health Advisor
CARE
What happens if we stop vaccinating
now?
"If we stop now we would never be able to stop
using the polio vaccine any place in the world. Because until you
totally eradicate this disease, the day you stop vaccinating every
child in the world for polio -- is the day it spreads back though
the entire world. And were back in the same situation we were
in the 40s and 50s. We're still vulnerable to this disease, and
until its eradicated from the world, every country is going
to be vulnerable."
Dr. Anthony Mounts
World Health Organization
|